Normal Value of Antistreptolysin O Titer in Rheumatoid Heart Disease who are on Secondary Prophylaxis and in Apparently Healthy Children at Debreberhan Referral Hospital, Ethiopia

Anti-streptolysin O (ASO) titer assists for the diagnosis of streptococcal infections and their sequele. Normal value of Anti-streptolysin O titer is not available for Ethiopian populations. These studies establishes and compare the normal reference value in Rheumatoid Heart Disease (RHD) and in apparently healthy children. A cross sectional study methods was employed to collect blood samples from RHD patients who are on secondary prophylaxis, and apparently healthy children at pediatric clinic of DebreBrehan referral hospital. The blood sample was collected for ASO titer determination. And finally, the data will be analyzed using SPSS version 21 and P-value less than or equal to 0.05 was taken as statistically significant. A total of 123 children on secondary prophylaxis for RHD in the age range of 5-15 years are included in this study. Of these, 65 (52.8) were male and 58 (47.2%) were female. The ASO ULN for the total subjects was 800 IU/ml. The ASO ULN for both male and female children in all age groups was also 800 IU/ml. And also 127 apparently healthy children with the age of 5-15 years were selected and investigated for the ASO ULN. The ASO ULN for the total subjects was 360 IU/ml. The ASO ULN for both male and female children was 320 IU/ml. The highest ASO ULN was observed for the age group of 9-12 years 400 IU/ml. These studies suggest, most children with RHD have recent streptococcal infection as evident by raised ASO titer. This study also showed that ASO ULN for apparently healthy children is almost similar to those reported in countries with different climates.

Keywords:Rheumatic Heart Disease; Apparently Healthy; ASO Titers; Normal Value

Rheumatic heart disease (RHD) remains a leading cause of morbidity and mortality among young adults in the developing world, accounting for at least 345,000 deaths annually [1,2]. RHD is the long term consequence of rheumatic fever, an autoimmune response to Group a streptococcal (GAS) pharyngitis [3]. Without prophylaxis, patients with RHD are at risk of recurrent attacks of rheumatic fever resulting in ongoing inflammation and fibrosis with consequent valvular damage [4,5]. Although its incidence is decreasing in industrialized countries, RHD remains a major challenge in the rest of the world. The highest prevalence is in sub-Saharan Africa with a rate of 5.7 per 1000, compared to 1.8 per 1000 in North Africa, and 0.3 per 1000 in economically advanced countries [6]. In Ethiopia, RHD is the number one cardiac problem in children with a prevalence rate of 4.6-7.1 per 1000 [7,8]. Particularly frustrating has been the fact that RHD are theoretically preventable but still remains a problem in developing countries. Reason most advanced is that these countries cannot afford the economic and social cost involved [9].

Rheumatic Heart Disease (RHD) are an autoimmune disease that follows infection with GAS; however, the isolation of GAS is uncommon (15%), and so confirmation of the diagnosis often relies on streptococcal antibody tests [10]. The most frequently performed test is ASO titer [11]. If possible, it is recommended that the titer be determined in the acute phase and then determined in the convalescent phase 14 to 28 days later, with a positive result defined as a rise in titer of twofold or more [12]. However, it is not always practicable to obtain a second sample for titer determination, particularly in developing countries, where acute rheumatic heart Disease is the most common. Therefore, it is generally accepted that if only a single specimen is available, a titer greater than the upper limit of normal at the initial testing can be considered presumptive evidence of a preceding streptococcal infection [12-14]. However, Because of the differences in ASO titers with age, it is recommended that age-stratified upper-limit-of-normal values should be determined for populations of interest by testing people who have not had a recent streptococcal infection. Yet, there has been no investigation of upper-limit-of-normal values for populations in Ethiopia. Thus conclusions drawn may be misleading. Therefore, this study aims to establish and compare normal range of ASO titers in rheumatic heart disease patients who are on secondary prophylaxis and in apparently healthy children among different age groups since ASO titer is common test in Ethiopia to diagnose RHD.

The study was conducted at pediatric clinic of Debre Brhan referral hospital from November, 2016 - September, 2017.

Cross sectional study design was employed

Inclusion Criteria: Convenient sampling technique was used to select 123 confirmed RHD patients who are on secondary antibiotic prophylaxis, and 127 apparently healthy children who are devoid of streptococcal infections. Those parents/guardians who give written informed consent and children who give verbal assent were included in the study.

Exclusion Criteria: Children with confirmed streptococcal infections other than those already developed RHD were excluded. Children with RHD who were visiting the follow up clinic for the first time and those not received secondary antibiotic prophylaxis were excluded.

A total of 3ml of venous blood was collected using sterile 5ml syringes from consecutive patients from November, 2016- September, 2017 at pediatric clinic of Debre Brhan referral hospital and immediately transferred to a glass tube without anticoagulant. It was transported to Debre Berhan university medical microbiology laboratory and then serum was used for ASO titer determination. The demographic data was collected using a questionnaire. Clinical information was obtained from all patients by reviewing medical records. Standard Operational Procedures were strictly followed during the whole laboratory procedures.

Data obtained from each samples was analyzed using SPSS version 21 software. A p-value of less than or equal to 0.05 was considered as statistically significant difference after correlation analysis. The mean, standard deviation, and median for ASO serum levels among the tested subjects were calculated. The median and cut of 80 percentile were used for normal ASO titer determination.

Ethical approval was obtained by Debre Brehan university research and review committee and official permission was obtained from head department of Debre Brehan referral hospital. Written informed consent was obtained from each child’s parent or guardian and assent from study participants older than 12 years.

A total of 123 children on secondary prophylaxis for RHD were recruited for ASO ULN. Of these, 65 (52.8) were male and 58 (47.2%) were female; 69 (56.1%) were from rural and 54 (43.9%) were from urban area. The children were symmetrically distributed in age groups and majority of the participant were in the age group of 9-12 years. This study shows the ASO ULN for the total subjects was 800 IU/ml with a median 400 IU/ml. The ASO ULN for both male and female children was 800 IU/ml with a median of 400 IU/ml. The ASO ULN was 800 IU/ml with a median of 400 IU/ml for all age groups (Table 1). Demographic data of patients such as neurological involvement, musculoskeletal, ECG findings, electrolyte imbalance were not obtained. However, all children take penicillin G as prophylaxis.

A total of 127 apparently healthy children with the age of 5-15 years, 68 (53.5%) male and 59 (46.5%) female were conveniently selected and investigated for ASO ULN. The children were symmetrically distributed in age groups, 42 (33.1%) were in age group of 5-8 years, 43 (33.8%) were in age group of 9-12 years and 42 (33.1%) were in age group of 13-15 years. The ASO ULN for the total subjects was 360 IU/ml with a median 200 IU/ml. The ASO ULN for both male and female children was 320 IU/ml with a median of 200 IU/ml. The highest ASO ULN was observed for the age group of 9-12 years (400 IU/ml with median of 200 IU/ml) (Table 2).

The diagnostic criteria of rheumatic heart disease is ASO level greater than 200 IU/ml. Anti-streptolyasin O (ASO) serum titer in excess of 200 IU/ml is considered abnormally high and suggest either recent infection with streptococci or persistently high antibody level due to earlier exposure in hypersensitive persons [14]. In our study a total of 123 patients of RHD were included. The ASO ULN for the total subjects was 800 IU/ml with a median 400 IU/ml. The ASO ULN for both male and female children was 800 IU/ml with a median of 400 IU/ml. The ASO ULN was 800 IU/ml with a median of 400 IU/ml for all age groups. Different study were indicated that in chronic RHD patients, ASO ULN was less than standard (200 IU/ml) due to the effect of penicillin on the immune response to streptococci, But in this study ASO ULN was higher (800 IU/ml) than standard (200 IU/ml). This might be attributed to the recent streptococcal infection in which (68 (55.3%) patients had ≤ 3 months duration of treatment [15].

The present study also designed to establish normal range of ASO titers in apparently healthy individuals among different age groups. Most of the reports in the literature dealing with "normal" ASO titers have been based on the study of healthy subjects. We chose pediatric patients with no clinical history of a recent streptococcal infection, rather than healthy subjects, for our study because study conducted in America considers that their titers are more relevant as a base line for suggesting what constitutes a significant ASO titer [14]. The reason for this is that the majority of serum specimens submitted to a laboratory for ASO tests will be from patients rather than from healthy subjects, even though the patients may not have a streptococcal infection. In present study the ASO ULN for the total subjects was 360 IU/ml with a median 200 IU/ml. The ASO ULN for both male and female children was 320 IU/ml with a median of 200 IU/ml. The highest ASO ULN was observed for the age group of 9-12 years (400 IU/ml with median of 200 IU/ml) followed by 360 IU/ml for the age group 5-8 years and age group 13-15 years with a median of 200 IU/ml. The ASO ULN in this study was found to be roughly similar to those reported from other regions. In comparison with data from the Minnesota, USA (333 Todd unit), Mumbai, India (305 IU/ml), Australia (320 IU/ml) and Korea (326 IU/ml) [15-18]. Relatively higher ASO ULN was obtained from study conducted in Sana'a, Yemen (276.2 IU/ml), Fiji (276 IU/ml), USA (240 IU/ml), Tanzania (200 IU/ml), Sweden (200 Todd’s unit) and in a different regions of India (239 IU/ml) [19-24]. However, lower result was obtained from study conducted in Egypt (400IU/ml) [25].

Most of these values exceeded the normal level set by laboratories which is 200 IU/mL. The higher ASO titers in Yemen and Australia, Fiji and India are probably due to the fact that tonsillitis and impetigo are endemic particularly in children [20,26]. In Ethiopia, RHD is the number one cardiac problem in children with a prevalence rate of 4.6-7.1 per 1000 suggest that there is high prevalence of tonsillitis and pharyngitis [7,8].

Different literature showed that simple non parametric method gives the cutoff values similar to those obtained by the parametric method. However, the parametric method for data analysis that was used in this study has some advantages over the non-parametric method. The non-parametric method often produces unlikely irregular patterns in the centiles with age, unless a large sample is used and wide age intervals are specified [20]. The results may be artificially affected by the choice of age groups, especially when titers have a complex pattern of change with age. This study will recommend that Ethiopians clinicians use single upper limit of normal cutoff value for children aged from 5 to 15 years rather than sub-age groups. This is because there is minor variability in the year by year values that was found in children aged 5 to 15 years. This study was also suggesting that the female cut off value equal to the male cut off value. This issue has not been discussed by other researchers previously.

These studies suggest that in most children with RHD; have recent streptococcal infection as evident by raised ASO ULN. This finding showed that ASO ULN for apparently healthy are much lower than children with RHD but similar to those reported in countries with different climates and populations and will provide useful baseline data for future studies of interventions against GAS disease in Ethiopia. These data could also be applied for the surrounding area in Ethiopia.

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

This work was funded from Debre Berhan University core budget.

TA-performed the laboratory activities. TA- analyzed the data and wrote the manuscript. DS, MT, TZ and NZ reviewed the manuscript. TA, DS, MT, TZ and NZ participated in its design. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

We would like to thank Debre Berhan University for giving this opportunity and its fund. We also thank staffs and head or director of Debre Berhan referral hospital for their help during data collection process.